- citati u SCIndeksu: [1]
- citati u CrossRef-u:0
- citati u Google Scholaru:[
]
- posete u poslednjih 30 dana:3
- preuzimanja u poslednjih 30 dana:3
|
|
2021, vol. 3, br. 2, str. 77-93
|
Odluka suda EU u slučaju Coman - indirektno priznanje istopolnog braka?
The ECJ's Coman judgment: Recognition of same-sex marriage indirectly?
Sažetak
U slučaju Coman, Evropskom sudu pravde je postavljeno pitanje da li pojam "bračni drug", u okolnostima koje ulaze u područje primene prava EU, uključuje istopolnog bračnog partnera građanina EU koji se seli iz jedne u drugu državu članicu. Sud je na ovo pitanje odgovorio afirmativno sa obrazloženjem da bi odbijanje priznanja istopolnog braka i sledstveno tome, odbijanje priznanja na spajanje porodice, predstavljalo neopravdano ograničenje prava na slobodno kretanje koje građani Unije uživaju prema pravu EU. Ova odluka je pozdravljena i proglašena prvim korakom u, mada indirektnom priznanju braka. U isto vreme, u vezi sa ovim slučajem su se otvorila brojna, značajna pitanja na koje će odgovore dati pravo i praksa u godinama koje slede.
Abstract
In the Coman case, the European Court of Justice was asked whether the term "spouse" - for the purpose of EU law - includes the same-sex spouse of an EU citizen who has moved between EU Member States. The ECJ answered this question affirmatively, holding that a refusal to recognise a same-sex marriage and the resultant refusal to grant family reunification rights to a Union citizen who moves to another Member State, would constitute an unjustified restriction on the right to free movement that Union citiyens enjoy under EU law. This case comment analyses the judgment, arguing that the Court's pronouncement is a very welcome first step towards marriage equality at a cross-border level in the EU. At the same time, the case poses a number of important questions, which will only be answered in case law and practice in the years to come.
|
|
|
Reference
|
|
Đurković, M. (2013) Homoseksualizam i popularna kultura. Politička revija, 37(3)
|
|
Kraljić, S. (2017) Same-sex partnerships in Eastern Europe: Marriage, Registration or no regulation?. u: Boele-Woelki Katharina ; Fuchs Angelika [ur.] Same-sex relationships and Beyond-Gender Matters in the EU, Intersentia, 3rd edition
|
5
|
Meškić, Z., Samardžić, D. (2012) Pravo Evropske Unije I. Sarajevo
|
|
Tryfonidou, A. (2019) An Analysis of the ECJ Ruling in Case C-673/16 Coman -The Right of Same-Sex Spouses under EU Law to Move Freely Between EU Member States. Research report for Nelfa, January 2019, www.nelfa.org. 2019/01 pdf
|
|
Vladimirovich, K.D., Belavusau, U. (2020) After the Celebration: Marriage equality in EU Law post-Coman in eight questions and some further thoughts. Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law, 27(5)
|
|
Vukadinović, R. (2006) Pravo EU. Kragujevac
|
|
|
|