- citations in SCIndeks: 0
- citations in CrossRef:0
- citations in Google Scholar:[
]
- visits in previous 30 days:5
- full-text downloads in 30 days:2
|
|
2022, vol. 61, iss. 96, pp. 145-159
|
Future things as an object of real rights
Buduća stvar kao predmet stvarnih prava
Abstract
The paper aims to answer the question whether the concept of " future things" is compatible with property relations by addressing the issues such as: future things as an object of real rights, future things as real securities, transfer of real rights on future things, and future things as an object of enforcement proceedings. The analysis provided in this paper shows the COVID-19 crisis has brought many repercussions, not only to the public health systems in Europe but also to the European economy that has sustained losses during the pandemic. In such dire conditions, certain Macedonian financial institutions (such as banks) have offered financial support to the government and have lobbied for some benefits in return. Unfortunately, the benefits that banks have lobbied for threaten the stability and consistency of the civil law system. The situation raises concern among scholars who have urged for the preservation of the civil law institutes so that the short-term legal solutions implemented in haste for the benefit of some entities (banks) will not cause irreparable long-term damage to the overall civil law system. The authors analyze the provisions of several Macedonian legislative acts that implement the concept of future things in some areas of property law, such as: the exercise of real rights on future things, future things as real securities, transfer of right on future things, and forced sale in enforcement proceedings. The main objective of the analysis is to demonstrate that regulating " future things" as an object of real rights is not sustainable due to the nature of these rights.
Sažetak
Ovaj rad daje odgovor na pitanje da li treba prihvatiti koncept da buduća stvar može biti stvar u stvarnopravnom smislu reči, tj. da li može biti objekt stvarnih prava, da li može biti predmet realnog obezbeđenja, da li se može s njom raspolagati (pustiti je u promet), i na kraju da li buduća stvar može biti predmet izvršenja u izvršnom postupku. Analiza pokazuje da je kriza prouzrokovana korona-virusom imala štetne posledice po zdravstvene sisteme evropskih zemalja koji su se našli u kolapsu, kao i po evropsku ekonomiju koja je pretrpela gubitke tokom pandemije.U tim uslovima, određene institucije u RS Makedoniji, kao što su banke, s jedne strane pružaju finansijsku pomoć državnim institucijama, a s druge strane traže pogodnosti koje, na žalost, dovode do urušavanja pravne prirode građanskopravnih instituta. Ovakva dvoličnost zabrinjava teoretičare građanskopravne nauke koji u ovim vanrednim okolnostima apeluje na očuvanje stabilnosti građanskopravnih instituta, kako ne bi došlo do još većih problema u održanju stvarnopravnih sistema i njihovog urušavanja radi zadovoljenja pojedinačnih potreba. Autorke ovog rada analiziraju određene građanskopravne odredbe u makedonskom pravu koje se odnose na buduće stvari u svim sferama stvarno-pravnog sistema (vršenje stvarnih prava na budućoj stvari, realno obezbeđenje na budućoj stvari, promet buduće stvari, i prinudno izvršenje na budućoj stvari). Izvršena kritička analiza ima za cilj da pokaže da se koncept normativnog uređenja buduće stvari ne uklapa u njenu pravnu prirodu kao objekata stvarnih prava.
|
|
|
References
|
|
*** (2016-2020) Zakon za izvršuvanje / Enforcement Act. Sl. vesnik na RM, br. 72/16, 142/16, 178/17, 26/18, 233/18, 14/2020 i 136/20
|
|
*** (2008-2015) Zakon za obligacionite i stvarnopravnite odnosi vo vozdušniot soobraќaj / Act on Obligations and Real Property Relations in Air Traffic. Sl. vesnik na RM, br. 85/08, 148/11, 10/15, 150/15
|
|
*** (2001-2013) Zakon na obligacionite odnosi Makedonije / Civil Obligations Act. Službeni Vesnik na Republika Makedonija, br. 18/01, 78/01, 04/02, 59/02, 05/03, 84/08, 81/09, 161/09, 23/13 i 123/13
|
|
*** (2001-2010) Zakon za sopstvenost i drugi stvarni prava / Act on Ownership and Other Real Rights. Služben vesnik na RM, br. 18/2001, 92/2008, 139/2009, 35/2010
|
|
*** (2007-2018) Zakon za vnatrešna plovidba / The Inland Navigation Act. Sl. vesnik na RM, br. 55/07, 26/09, 22/10, 23/11, 53/11, 155/12, 15/13, 137/13, 163/13, 42/14, 166/14, 146/15, 193/15, 31/16, 64/18
|
|
*** (2010-2021) Zakon za gradenje / The Construction Act. Sl. vesnik na RM, br. 124/10, 18/11, 18/11, 36/11, 49/11, 54/11, 13/12, 144/12, 25/13, 79/13, 137/13, 163/13, 27/14, 28/14, 42/14, 115/14, 149/14, 187/14, 44/15, 129/15, 129/15, 217/15, 226/15, 30/16, 31/16, 39/16, 71/
|
|
*** (2003-2016) Zakon za dogovoren zalog / Contractual Pledge Act. Sl. vesnik na RM, br. 5/03, 4/05, 87/07, 51/11, 74/12, 115/14, 98/15, 215/15, 61/16
|
|
*** (2013-2019) Zakon za katastar na nedvižnosti / The Real Estate Cadastre Act. Sl. vesnik na RM + Sl. vesnik RSM, br. 55/13, 41/14, 115/14, 116/15, 153/15, 192/15, 61/16, 172/16 i 64/18, br. 124/19
|
|
Atias, Ch. (1999) Droit civil: Les biens. Paris: Litec, quatrième édition
|
|
Gavella, N., Gliha, I., Josipović, T., Stipković, Z. (1992) Odabrane teme iz stvarnog prava / Selected Real Property Law Topics. Zagreb: Pravni fakultet u Zagrebu
|
|
Grupče, A. (1983) Imotno (Graѓansko) pravo - opšt del / Property Law. Skopje: Kultura
|
|
Živkovska, R. (2005) Stvarno pravo / Real Property Law. Skopje: Evropa 92
|
|
|
|