Belgrade Philosophical Annual
how to cite this article
share this article


  • citations in SCIndeks: 0
  • citations in CrossRef:0
  • citations in Google Scholar:[]
  • visits in previous 30 days:3
  • full-text downloads in 30 days:2


article: 1 from 1  
2021, vol. 1, iss. 34, pp. 95-111
Hume's sentimentalism: Not non-cognitivism
Stockholm University, Sweden
Keywords: cognitivism; Hume; internalism; motivation; non-cognitivism
This paper considers and argues against old and recent readings of Hume according to which his account of moral judgement is non-cognitivist. In previous discussions of this topic, crucial metaethical distinctions-between sentimentalism and non-cognitivism and between psychological and semantic non-cognitivism-are often blurred. The paper aims to remedy this and argues that making the appropriate metaethical distinctions undermines alleged support for non-cognitivist interpretations of Hume. The paper focuses in particular on Hume's so-called 'motivation argument' and argues that it is a poor basis for non-cognitivist interpretations. While there is textual support for attributing to Hume what may be called 'modally weak' motivational internalism, there is no solid textual support for attributing to him either psychological or semantic non-cognitivism. The paper also challenges briefly some further alleged support for non-cognitivist interpretations. It concludes by offering some positive evidence against such interpretations, namely that Hume appears to hold that there are moral beliefs and moral knowledge.
*** (2000) A Treatise of Human Nature. Oxford: Clarendon Press
*** (1978) A Treatise of Human Nature. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2nd edn
*** (1998) An Enquiry concerning the Principles of Morals. Oxford: Oxford University Press
*** (1994) Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund
*** (2008) Hume's Morality: Feeling and Fabrication. Oxford: Oxford University Press
*** (2018) Hume, Passion, and Action. Oxford: Oxford University Press
*** (1999) An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding. Oxford: Clarendon Press
*** (2010) Snare's Puzzle/Hume's Purpose: Non-Cognitivism and What Hume was Really Up To with No-Ought-From-Is. in: Pigden C. [ed.] Hume on Is and Ought, Basingstoke: Palgrave, 169-191
*** (2009) Hume on Motivation and Virtue. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan
*** (2009) The Motivation Argument for Non-Cognitivism. Pigden [ed.] 105-125
Blackburn, S. (2015) Hume, Morality, and Skepticism. in: Russell P. [ed.] The Oxford Handbook of Hume, Oxford: Oxford University Press
Botros, S. (2006) Hume, Reason, and Morality. London: Routedge
Bricke, J. (1996) Mind and Morality. Oxford: Clarendon Press
Brown, C. (1988) Is Hume an Internalist?. Journal of the History of Philosophy, 26: 69-87
Chamberlain, J. (2019) Hume's Emotivist Theory of Moral Judgements. European Journal of Philosophy, 28: 1058-72
Cohon, R. (1997) Is Hume a Non-Cognitivist in the Motivation Argument?. Philosophical Studies, 85: 251-66
Cohon, R., Owen, D. (1997) Hume on Representation, Reason, and Motivation. Manuscrito, 20: 47-76
Flew, A. (1963) On the Interpretation of Hume. Philosophy, 38: 178-82
Fogelin, R. (1979) Review of Jonathan Harrison, Hume's Moral Epistemology. Noûs, 13: 523-528
Hare, R.M. (1952) The Language of Morals. Oxford: Clarendon Press
Howard, S.J. (2009) Walls and Vaults: A Natural Science of Morals (Virtue Ethics According to David Hume). Hoboken, N.J: Wiley
Hume, D. (1975) Enquiries concerning Human Understanding and concerning the Principles of Morals. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 3rd edn
Joyce, R. (2009) Expressivism, Motivation Internalism, and Hume. Pigden [ed.] 30-56
Kail, P.J.E. (2007) Projection and Realism in Hume's Philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press
Lo, N.Y.S. (2009) Is Hume Inconsistent?: Motivation and Morals'. Pigden [ed.] 57-79
Mackie, John Leslie (1980) Hume's Moral Theory. London: Routledge
Pigden, C. (2009) If Not Non-Cognitivism, Then What?. Pigden [ed.] 80-104
Radcliffe, E. (2006) Moral Internalism and Moral Cognitivism in Hume's Metaethics'. Synthese, 152: 353-70
Ridge, M. (2007) Ecumenical Expressivism: The Best of Both Worlds. in: Shafer-Landau R. [ed.] Oxford Studies in Metaethics, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2: 51-76
Sayre-Mccord, G. (2008) Hume on Practical Morality and Inert Reason. in: R. Shafer-Landau [ed.] Oxford Studies in Metaethics, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 3: 299-320
Shecaira, F. (2011) Hume and Non-Cognitivism. History of Philosophy Quarterly, 28: 267-87
Smith, M. (1994) The Moral Problem. Oxford: Blackwell
Snare, F. (1991) Morals, Motivation, and Convention: Hume's Influential Doctrines. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Sturgeon, N. (2008) Hume's Metaethics: Is Hume a Moral Noncognitivist?. in: Radcliffe E. S. [ed.] A Companion to Hume, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 513-541


article language: English
document type: Original Scientific Paper
DOI: 10.5937/BPA2134095O
published in SCIndeks: 10/07/2021