- citati u SCIndeksu: 0
- citati u CrossRef-u:0
- citati u Google Scholaru:[
]
- posete u poslednjih 30 dana:6
- preuzimanja u poslednjih 30 dana:6
|
|
2021, vol. 59, br. 1, str. 35-51
|
Međunarodno investiciono pravo i zaštita radnih prava - standard poštenog i pravičnog tretmana i indirektna eksproprijacija u svetlu izmena radnopravnih propisa države domaćina
International investment law and labour rights protection: A standard of fair and equitable treatment and indirect expropriation in the light of changes in host country labour law
Sažetak
Cilj ovog rada je da odgovori na pitanje da li ulagači mogu osporiti domaće radno zakonodavstvo pozivajući se na povrede međunarodnih ugovora o podsticanju i zaštiti ulaganja, i to povredu standarda pravičnog i poštenog tretmana, kao i nezakonitu eksproprijaciju ulaganja. Odgovor na ovo pitanje je naročito relevantan za države u razvoju, poput Republike Srbije, koje nastoje da usklade svoj pravni poredak sa međunarodnim principima zaštite radnih prava. Stoga će u radu biti analizirana tumačenja standarda pravičnog i poštenog tretmana i indirektne eksproprijacije data od strane arbitražnih tribunala i prihvaćena u naučnoj literaturi, kao i njihova primena u svetlu izmena radnopravnih propisa.
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to answer the question whether investors may challenge domestic labour legislation by invoking breach of international investment agreements, in particular violations of fair and equitable treatment standard, as well as illegal expropriation of investments. The answer to this question is especially relevant for developing countries, such as the Republic of Serbia, which seek to harmonize their legal systems with international principles of labour rights protection. Therefore, the paper will explore the interpretations of the fair and equitable treatment standard and indirect expropriation given by arbitration tribunals and accepted among scholars, as well as their application with respect to the labour regulation changes. Particularly analysed is the relevant case law before arbitration tribunals dealing with the question whether host states may violate these standards by amending their domestic labour legislation. Research has shown that domestic labour regulation amendments may rarely be interpreted as indirect expropriation, while the fair and equitable treatment standard may be breached in case of unpredictable labour legislation changes which would significantly violate guarantees given by the state to attract foreign investments but cannot protect investors from the introduction of bona fide labour regulations.
|
|
|
Reference
|
|
Barnali, C. (2019) Investor obligations for human rights. u: ICSID review (Forthcoming), dostupno na adresi: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3500991, 10. 1. 2021
|
|
Brower, C., Blanchard, S. (2014) What's in a meme?: The truth about investor-state arbitration: Why it need not, and must not, be repossessed by states. Columbia Journal of Transnational Law, Vol. 52, Nr. 3
|
|
Charlotin, D. (2018) Egyptian official confirms victory in Veolia case at ICSID, as company remains silent. Investment Arbitration Reporter, dostupno na adresi: https://www.iareporter.com/articles/egyptianofficial-confirms-victory-in-veolia-case-at-icsid-as-company-remainssilent/, 30. 12. 2020
|
|
Dolzer, R., Bloch, F. (2003) Indirect expropriation: Conceptual realignments. International Law FORUM Du Droit International, Nr. 3
|
3
|
Dolzer, R., Schreuer, C. (2012) Principles of international investment law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd ed
|
2
|
Đundić, P. (2014) Legitimna očekivanja kao element standarda poštenog i pravičnog tretmana stranih ulaganja u arbitražnoj praksi. Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta, Novi Sad, vol. 48, br. 2, str. 335-351
|
|
Kingsbury, B., Schill, S.W. (2010) Public law concepts to balance investors' rights with state regulatory actions in the public interest-the concept of proportionality. u: Schill, Stephan W. [ur.] International investment law and comparative public law, Oxford University Press (OUP), str. 75-104
|
|
Kriebaum, U. (2013) Are investment treaty standards flexible enough to meet the needs of developing countries?. u: Baetens, Freya [ur.] Investment law within international law: Integrationist perspectives, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
|
|
Kube, V., Petersmann, E. (2016) Human rights law in international investment arbitration. EUI Department of Law Research Paper, No. 02, dostupno na adresi: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2731770, 10. 1. 2021
|
|
Maletić, K. (2020) Investor obligations under international law to respect labour rights and to comply with international labour standards. dostupno na adresi: https://scripties.uba.uva.nl/search?id=c2971313, 11. 1. 2021
|
|
Peterson, E.L. (2012) French company, Veolia, launches claim against Egypt over terminated waste contract and labor wage stabilization promises. Investment Arbitration Reporter, dostupno na adresi: https://www.iareporter.com/articles/french-company-veolia-launchesclaim-against-egypt-over-terminated-waste-contract-and-labor-wagestabilization-promises/, 30. 12. 2020
|
|
Prislan, V., Zandvliet, R. (2013) Labor provisions in international investment agreements: Prospects for sustainable development. Grotius Centre Working Paper 003-IEL, dostupno na adresi: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2171716, 10. 1. 2021
|
|
Shemberg, A. (2008) Investment agreements and human rights: The effects of stabilization clauses. Working Paper No. 42, dostupno na adresi: https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/fi les/centers/mrcbg/ programs/cri/fi les/workingpaper_42_shemberg.pdf, 11. 1. 2021
|
|
Sheppard, A.W., Crockett, A. (2011) Are stabilization clauses a threat to sustainable development?. u: Cordonier Segger, Marie-Claire; Gehring, Markus W.; Newcombe, Andrew [ur.] Sustainable development in world investment law, The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International
|
|
Ursula, K. (2009) Human rights of the population of the host state in international investment arbitration. Journal of World Investment & Trade, Nr. 5
|
|
Vis-Dunbar, D. (2009) South African court judgment bolsters expropriation charge over black economic empowerment legislation in the mining sector. dostupno na adresi: https://cf.iisd.net/itn/2009/03/23/ south-african-court-judgment-bolsters-expropriation-charge-over-blackeconomic-empowerment-legislation/, 6. 1. 2021
|
|
Zandvliet, R. (2019) Trade, investment and labour: Interactions in international law. doctoral thesis, Universiteit Leiden, Leiden
|
|
|
|