Akcije

Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu
kako citirati ovaj članak
podeli ovaj članak
Direktan link

Metrika

  • citati u SCIndeksu: [2]
  • citati u CrossRef-u:0
  • citati u Google Scholaru:[]
  • posete u poslednjih 30 dana:1
  • preuzimanja u poslednjih 30 dana:0

Sadržaj

članak: 4 od 11  
Back povratak na rezultate
Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu
2019, vol. 67, br. 1, str. 67-92
The perfect silence: An empirical study on how ignorance and lack of critical debate effect the process of enacting tax legislation in Serbia
(naslov ne postoji na srpskom)
Kostić Svetislav V., Vuković Danilo
Univerzitet u Beogradu, Pravni fakultet, Srbija

e-adresa: skostic@ius.bg.ac, danilo.vukovic@ius.bg.ac.rs
Projekat:
Project of the University of Belgrade, Faculty of Law: Identity transformation of Serbia

Ključne reči: Fair and sustainable taxation; Democracy; Lawmaking; Policymaking; Tax policy; Professional expertise; Corruption
Sažetak
(ne postoji na srpskom)
In this paper the authors deal with the crucial question of the ability of the Serbian institutions and society to apply adequate scrutiny with respect to the enactment of tax legislation. After providing a description of the current Serbian law-making and public consultations framework, and analyzing the relevance of the transitional nature of the Serbian political environment on the approach to the business of legislating, the authors choose three case studies which lead to the conclusion that it is the lack of even basic knowledge regarding taxation, at the level of the members of parliament and the media, combined with the silence and inertness of Serbian professional circles to participate in public debates on tax policy, that is enabling many questionable norms to enter Serbian legislation without any notable opposition or deliberation. Finally, the authors propose certain measures that could improve the public consultations process.
Reference

*** (2015) Basic measurement report: The principles of public administration: Serbia. Paris: OECD/SIGMA

*** The Mahabharata, book 12: Santi Parva, part I: Rajadharmanusasana Parva. Section LXXXVIII, translation by K.M. Ganguli, http://sacred-texts.com/hin/m12/m12a087.htm, 11 February 2019

*** (2010) The principles of tax policy. u: Eight Report of Session 2010-2011, Treasury Committee of the UK House of Commons, https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmselect/cmtreasy/753/753.pdf, 11 February 2019

Ágh, A. (1997) Parliaments as Policy-making Bodies in East Central Europe: The Case of Hungary. International Political Science Review, 18(4): 417-432

Amenta, E. (2005) State-Centered and Political Institutional Theory: Retrospect and Prospect. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Antonić, S. (2006) Elite, građani i slaba država. Belgrade: Službeni glasnik

1

Brinton, M., Nee, V., ur. (1998) The New Institutionalism in Sociology. New York: Russell Sage Foundation

Cohen, L., Lampe, J. (2011) Embracing democracy in the Western Balkans: From postconflict struggles toward european integration. Washington, D.C: Woodrow Wilson Center Press

Cvejić, S., ur. (2016) Informal Power Networks, Political Patronage and Clientelism in Serbia and Kosovo. Belgrade: SeConS

1

de Crouy-Chanel, E., de la Motte, M.A. (2010) France. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vol. 7

del Fedreico, L., Castigione, R., Miconi, F. (2010) Italy. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vol. 7

Dourado, A.P. (2010) General report: In search of validity in tax law: The boundaries between creation and application in a rule-of-law state. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vo. 7

1

Džinić, J. (2011) Public Administration Reform in Serbia. Hrvatska i komparativna javna uprava: časopis za teoriju i praksu javne uprave, 11

Erdos, G. (2015) Depicting national tax: Hungary. u: Nykiel W., Sek M. [ur.] Tax Legislation - Standards, Trends and Challenges, Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer SA

4

Eriksen, S. (2007) Institution Building in Central and Eastern Europe: Foreign Influences and Domestic Responses. Review of Central and East European Law, 32(3): 333-369

Freedman, J. (2015) Managing tax complexity: The institutional framework for tax policy-making and oversight. u: Working Paper 15/08, Oxford University Center for Business Taxation, May 2015, 6-9, http://eureka.sbs.ox.ac.uk/5432/1/WP1508.pdf

1

Goetz, K.H., Zubek, R. (2007) Government, Parliament and Law-making in Poland. Journal of Legislative Studies, 13(4): 517-538

1

Gribnau, H. (2010) Netherlands. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vol. 7

Gribnau, H. (2013) Equality, Legal Certainty and Tax Legislation in the Netherlands Fundamental Legal Principles as Checks on Legislative Power: A Case Study. Utrecht Law Review, 9(2): 52

Hall, P.A., Taylor, R.C. R. (1996) Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms. Political Studies, 44(5): 936-957

Heinrich, J., Prinz, I. (2010) Austria. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vol. 7

Heymann, P.B. (1996-1997) Democracy and corruption. u: 20 Fordham Int'l L.J

Ilić-Popov, G., Popović, D. (2008) Oporezivanje kapitalnih dobitaka u srpskom poreskom pravu - tri razloga za zabrinutost poreskih pravnika. u: Taboroši S. [ur.] Razvoj pravnog sistema Srbije i harmonizacija sa pravom Evropske unije, Belgrade: University of Belgrade - Faculty of Law

Ilić-Popov, G., Kostić, S. (2015) Depicting national tax legislation: Serbia. u: Nykiel W., Sek M. [ur.] Tax Legislation - Standards, Trends and Challenges, Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer SA

2

Ilić-Popov, G., Popović, D. (2014) Poreska struktura i korupcija. Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu, vol. 62, br. 1, str. 5-22

Jelinčić, J., Đurović, S., ur. (2011) Evropeizacija Srbije. Belgrade: Građansko društvo / Fund for Open Society

Kaminski, A. (1997) Corruption Under the Post-Communist Transformation: The Case of Poland. Polish Sociological Review, 2

Kimura, K. (2010) Japan. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vol. 7

1

Kopecký, P. (2004) Power to the executive! the changing executive-legislative relations in eastern Europe. Journal of Legislative Studies, 10(2-3): 142-153

1

Kostić, S. (2016) Administrativni okvir kao ključna prepreka usklađivanju srpskog poreskog prava sa pravom Evropske unije. u: Radović V. [ur.] Usklađivanje poslovnog prava Srbije sa pravom Evropske unije, Belgrade: University of Belgrade - Faculty of Law

1

Kostić, S. (2006) Oporezivanje kapitalnih dobitaka fizičkih lica ostvarenih prodajom imovine stečene poklonom. Pravni život, vol. 55, br. 10, str. 909-919

Kuhner, T.K. (2015/2016) The Corruption of Liberal and Social Democracies. Fordham L. Rev., 84

Laušev, J. (2012) Public sector pay gap in Serbia during large-scale privatisation, by educational qualification. Ekonomski anali, vol. 57, br. 192, str. 7-24

1

Lazić, M. (2011) Čekajući kapitalizam. Belgrade: Službeni glasnik

Lazić, M., Pešić, J. (2012) Making and Unmaking State-Centered Capitalism in Serbia. Belgrade: Čigoja

Martindale, B. C., Koch, B. S., Karlinsky, S. S. (1992) Tax Law Complexity: The Impact of Style. Journal of Business Communication, 29(4): 383-400

Mendelski, M. (2013) They Have Failed Again!, Donor-Driven Promotion of the Rule of Law in Serbia. Südosteuropa, 61

Milovanović, D., i dr. (2012) Studija o unapređenju zakonodavnog procesa u Republici Srbiji. Belgrade, http://www.transparentnost.org.rs/images/publikacije/GIZ%20srpski%20zasticena%20verzija%20(1).pdf

Mössner, J.M. (2015) Tax legislation in Germany: Procedures, actors, results, critics. u: Nykiel W., Sek M. [ur.] Tax Legislation - Standards, Trends and Challenges, Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer SA

Nielsen, J.G. (2010) Denmark. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vol. 7

3

Pajvančić, M. (2008) Parlamentarno pravo. Belgrade: Konrad Adenauer Foundation

Pavlović, V., Orlović, S., ur. (2007) Dileme i izazovi parlamentarizma. Belgrade: Fakultet političkih nauka / Fondacija Konrad Adenauer

Pedersen, F.H. (2011-2012) Advancing the study of tax complexity with the usability model. Hous. Bus. & Tax L. J, 12

1

Peters, B., van de Velde, E. (2010) Belgium. u: Dourado A.P. [ur.] Separation of Powers in Tax Law - 2009 EATLP Congress, Santiago de Compostela, EATLP International Tax Series Vol. 7

1

Pettai, V., Madise, Ü. (2006) The Baltic parliaments: Legislative performance from independence to EU accession. Journal of Legislative Studies, 12(3-4): 291-310

47

Popović, D. (2018) Poresko pravo. Belgrade: University of Belgrade Faculty of Law

Rose-Ackerman, S. (1996) Corruption and Democracy. Proceedings of the ASIL Annual Meeting, 90: 83-90

Stojanović, D. (2008) Kaldrma i asfalt: urbanizacija i evropeizacija Beograda 1890-1914. Belgrade: Udruženje za društvenu istoriju

Stone, R. (2016) Legal Design for the 'Good Man'. Va. L. Rev, 102

Teachout, Z. (2008-2009) The anti-corruption principle. Cornell L. Rev, 94

7

Thuronyi, V. (2003) Comparative Tax Law. The Hague: Kluwer Law International

Verheijen, T.J. G., Rabrenovic, A. (2015) Civil Service Development in Central and Eastern Europe and the CIS: A Perfect Storm?. London: Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 15-37

1

Vukadinović, S. (2015) Značaj i primena javnog slušanja na nacionalnom i lokalnom nivou. Pravni zapisi, vol. 6, br. 1, str. 26-51

Vukadinović, S. (2016) Javno razmatranje u funkciji prevazilaženja demokratskog deficita, javna rasprava i razgraničenje od javnog slušanja. Pravni zapisi, vol. 7, br. 1, str. 20-54

4

Vukelić, J. (2009) Neposredno učešće građana u donošenju odluka na lokalnom nivou vlasti u Srbiji. Sociologija, vol. 51, br. 3, str. 291-312

Vukovic, D. (2016) Capturing resources: The role of professional communities and middle classes in fostering social reforms within Serbia. Sociologija, 58(2): 253-279

Vuković, D. (2013) Kako nastaju zakoni u Srbiji - uloga društvenih interesa i institucija u zakonodavnom procesu. Belgrade: SeConS

Vuković, D. (2018) The hollowing out of institutions: Law- and policymaking in contemporary Serbia. u: Fekete B., Gárdos-Orosz F. [ur.] Central and Eastern European Socio-Political and Legal Transition Revisited, Peter Lang

Vuković, D., Cvejić, S. (2019) Attitudes to the rule of law in contemporary Serbia: A coherent legal culture. Jahrbuch für Ostrecht, 1, (forthcoming)

1

Vuković, D. (2015) The role of civil society in fostering government accountability in contemporary Serbia: On the limits of depoliticized social activism. Sociologija, vol. 57, br. 4, str. 637-661

Yingling, P.M. (2013) Conventional and unconventional corruption. Duq. L. Rev, 51

Zelenak, L. (2010) Complex Tax Legislation in the TurboTax Era. Columbia Journal of Tax Law, 1

Žarković, R.J. (2017) Kako se Srbiji dogodila visoka nejednakost u raspodeli dohotka. MONS, 1, http://mons.rs/kako-se-srbiji-dogodila-visoka-nejednakost-u-raspodeli-dohotka, 11 February 2019
   

O članku

jezik rada: engleski
vrsta rada: članak
DOI: 10.5937/AnaliPFB1901069K
objavljen u SCIndeksu: 28.03.2019.
Creative Commons License 4.0

Povezani članci

Nema povezanih članaka