Metrics

  • citations in SCIndeks: 0
  • citations in CrossRef:0
  • citations in Google Scholar:[]
  • visits in previous 30 days:9
  • full-text downloads in 30 days:0

Contents

article: 10 from 13  
Back back to result list
2015, vol. 17, iss. 1, pp. 27-41
Good faith acquisition of used motor vehicles purchased abroad: Some observations and critical remarks on Serbian case law
University of Kragujevac, Faculty of Law

emailslavko.djordjevic77@gmail.com
Keywords: acquisition of ownership in good faith; used motor vehicles; changing the situs of the vehicles; private international law; case law
Abstract
In the past decade Serbian courts have discussed several cases in which the main legal issue was whether the Serbian citizen who bought a used motor vehicle with hidden deficiencies from a non-owner (car dealer) in a foreign country acquired the ownership of that vehicle in good faith. In all these cases the courts directly applied Serbian property law, failing to recognize the presence of a foreign element in the legal dispute, i.e. the fact that the purchase and delivery of the vehicle occurred in a foreign country. The appearance of a foreign element in the legal relationship obliges the courts to apply the rules of private international law (i.e. conflict rules) in order to determine which national law (domestic or foreign) shall be applicable to the case. These rules have been ignored by Serbian courts which consequently led to direct application of Serbian rules on good faith acquisition that were more favorable than the rules of the law of a foreign country whose application would had been ordered by Serbian conflict rules. In this paper the author deals with the problem above by analyzing and discussing the Serbian substantial law on good faith acquisition of ownership (particularly of motor vehicles), Serbian rules of private international law as well as Serbian case law in this matter.
References
*** (1982) Zakon o rešavanju sukoba zakona sa propisima drugih zemalja. Official Gazette SFRY, No. 43
Babić, D., Jessel-Holst, C. (2011) Međunarodno privatno pravo - zbirka unutarnjih, europskih i međunarodnih propisa, Zagreb. Narodne novine, p. 4
Delibašić, T. (1996) Posebni uslovi i osnovi sticanja svojine od nevlasnika. Sudska praksa, br. 3, str. 76
Dik, M., Knežević, G., Stojanović, S. (1991) Komentar zakona o međunarodnom privatnom i procesnom pravu. Beograd, p. 69
Drobnig, U. (2006) Recognition and Adaptation of Foreign Security Rights, Divergences of Property Law, an Obstacle to the Internal Market (eds. U. Drobnig, H. J. p. 105
Đorđević, S. (2013) Transpozicija stranih stvarnih prava na pokretnim stvarima prema nacrtu zakona o međunarodnom privatnom pravu. Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu, vol. 61, br. 1, str. 149-168
Jakšić, A. (2008) Međunarodno privatno pravo. Beograd, p. 489-490
Kegel, G., Schurig, K. (2000) Internationales Privatrecht. München, S. 668
Kropholler, J. (2001) Internationales Privatrecht. Tübingen, S. 526
Mcclean, M.D., Beevers, K. (2005) The Conflict of Laws. London, p. 409; 6. ed
Planojević, N. (2008) Sticanje svojine od nevlasnika. Kragujevac, p. 160
Polak, M.V. (2006) Recognition Enforcement and Transformation of Foreign Proprietary Rights - a handful of observation and suggestions, Divergences of Property Law, an Obstacle to the Internal Market?, (eds. U. Drobnig, H. J. p. 117
Prütting, H. (2010) Sachenrecht. S. 180; 34
Stanković, O., Orlić, M. (1996) Stvarno pravo. Beograd, p. 80
Varadi, T., Bordaš, B., Knežević, G., Pavić, V. (2007) Međunarodno privatno pravo. Beograd, p. 101-102
von Hoffmann, B., Thorn, K. (2007) Internationales Privatrecht. München, S. 523
 

About

article language: English
document type: Paper
published in SCIndeks: 06/11/2015