- citations in SCIndeks: 0
- citations in CrossRef:0
- citations in Google Scholar:[
]
- visits in previous 30 days:47
- full-text downloads in 30 days:36
|
|
2022, vol. 94, iss. 1, pp. 224-239
|
Quackery as a criminal offence
Krivično delo nadrilekarstvo
Abstract
Acquiring appropriate professional qualifications enables one to provide certain medical treatments or other medical services. As the acquisition of material gain is often the motive for committing numerous criminal offenses as prescribed by the Criminal Code of the Republic of Serbia, it is often so with the criminal offense of quackery found in Article 254 of the Criminal Code. The reason for prescribing this act and sanctioning the perpetrator is that undertaking actions that require special education in the field of medicine without having it can cause damage to the health of another person, to a higher or lower degree. However, the sanctions occur regardless of whether in the specific case there was a consequence in the form of damage to or deterioration of the health of another person, as well as in the case when the perpetrator did not obtain material gain by taking specific actions without proper professional qualifications. Despite the fact that are witness to numerous testimonies of victims through the media, who out of ignorance decided to entrust their health to persons without proper qualifications, practice shows that a small number of criminal complaints is received by competent prosecutor's offices in Serbia and that a small number of court proceedings are conducted to prove guilt and the existence of a criminal offense.
Sažetak
Sticanje odgovarajuće stručne spreme omogućava preduzimanje određenih radnji koje predstavljaju lečenje ili pružanje drugih medicinskih usluga. Kako je sticanje imovinske koristi često pokretač vršenja brojnih krivičnih dela, predviđenih Krivičnim zakonikom Republike Srbije, to često biva i sa krivičnim delom nadrilekarstvo iz člana 254. KZ-a. Razlog propisivanja ovog dela i sankcionisanja učinioca jeste taj što nestručno preduzimanje radnji za koje je neophodno posebno obrazovanje iz oblasti medicine, može izazvati oštećenje zdravlja drugog lica, koje može biti manjih ili većih razmera. Međutim, do sankcionisanja dolazi bez obzira na to da li je u konkretnom slučaju nastupila posledica u vidu oštećenja ili pogoršanja zdravlja drugog lica, kao i u slučaju kad izvršilac krivičnog dela nije pribavio imovinsku korist preduzimanjem konkretnih radnji bez odgovarajuće stručne spreme. Uprkos činjenici da smo svedoci brojnog oglašavanja žrtava putem medija, koji su iz neznanja odlučili da svoje zdravlje povere nestručnim licima, praksa pokazuje da je mali broj podnetih krivičnih prijava koje pristižu nadležnim tužilaštvima na nivou Srbije, te da se vodi mali broj sudskih postupaka radi dokazivanja krivice i postojanja krivičnog dela.
|
|
|
References
|
|
*** (2019) Zakon o zdravstvenoj zaštiti. Službeni glasnik RS, br. 25
|
|
*** (2020) Pravilnik o bližim uslovima i načinu obavljanja metoda i postupaka komplementarne medicine. Službeni glasnik RS, br. 1
|
|
*** (2011-2021) Kazneni zakon Hrvatske. Narodne novine, br. 125/11, 144/12, 56/15, 61/15, 101/17, 118/18, 126/19, 84/21, na snazi od 31. 7. 2021. godine
|
|
*** (2005-2019) Krivični zakonik RS. Službeni glasnik RS, br. 85/2005, 88/2005. - ispr., 107/2005. - ispr., 72/2009, 111/2009, 121/2012, 104/2013, 108/2014, 94/2016. i 35/2019
|
|
*** EU Registar kvalificiranih iscjelitelja i terapeuta. Preuzeto dana 24. 9. 2021. godine sa: https://www.huped.hr/hr/hrvatski-registar-kvalificiranih-iscjelitelja-i-terapeuta-2
|
|
*** (2005) Evropska konvencija za zaštitu ljudskih prava i osnovnih sloboda sa dodatnim protokolima br. 4, 6, 7, 11, 12 i 13 od 1950. godine. Službeni list SCG - Međunarodni ugovori, br. 5/2005. i 7/2005
|
|
*** (2018) Stručno metodološko uputstvo za obavljanje metoda 'antiage' medicine. roj: 500-01-1246/2018-02, 19. 9. 2018
|
|
*** (2006) Ustav RS. Službeni glasnik RS, br. 98
|
|
*** (1983) Unproven methods of cancer management: Antineoplaston. CA: A Cancer journal for clinicians
|
|
Block, K.I. (2004) Antineoplastons and the challenges of research in integrative care. Integrative Cancer Therapies, 3(1), 3-4
|
|
Committee for Skeptical Inquiry Center for Inquiry (2017) Burzynski sanctioned by Texas medical board. Skeptical Inquirer, 41 (4)
|
|
Grundler-Bencarić, A. (2017) Komplementarna vs, Alternativna medicina. in: Adiva Savjetom do zdravlja
|
|
James Randi Educational Foundation REF's Pigasus awards 'Honors' dubious peddlers of 'Woo'. 1. 4. 2013, 'JREF's Pigasus Awards 'Honors' Dubious Peddlers of 'Woo'
|
|
Jovašević, D. (2017) Krivično pravo posebni deo. Belgrade: Dosije studio
|
|
Ramsland, K. (2007) Inside the minds of healthcare serial killers: Why they kill. Praeger Publishers
|
|
|
|