2016, vol. 68, iss. 3, pp. 108-121
|
Intelligence services and national security
Obaveštajne službe i nacionalna bezbednost
International University of Novi Pazar, Department of Law Studies
Abstract
The paper discusses the relationship between intelligence services and national security, or the significance of intelligence services’ impact on the national security of any country. The author starts by stating that this relationship is often simplified, within the following pattern: domestic intelligence services (always) work towards achieving and preserving the national security of their own country, and foreign intelligence services (always) threaten and impair this security. Using the comparative historical method and methods of analysis and synthesis, the author subjects this pattern to criticism, stating, first, that domestic intelligence services (both at national and subnational level), in addition to the expected positive, i.e. constructive action, may also act destructively to national security. On the other hand, he maintains that foreign intelligence services, in addition to predominantly destructive effect on national security of other countries, may also have a positive impact. Offering ample evidence for both of these assertions, the author concludes that the relationship between the intelligence services and national security is much more complex than many people might think, and that it does not do with any simplifying and easily launched patterns.
Sažetak
U radu se razmatra odnos obaveštajnih službi i nacionalne bezbednosti, odnosno značaj delovanja obaveštajnih službi na nacionalnu bezbednost bilo koje pojedinačne države. Autor polazi od konstatacije da se taj odnos često sagledava pojednostavljeno, u okviru sledeće šeme: domaće obaveštajne službe (uvek) rade na dostizanju i očuvanju nacionalne bezbednosti svoje zemlje, a strane službe (uvek) ugrožavaju i narušavaju tu bezbednost. Služeći se uporedno istorijskim metodom i metodima analize i sinteze, autor podvrgava kritici ovu šemu, utvrđujući, najpre, da domaće obaveštajne službe (i na nacionalnom i na subnacionalnom nivou), pored očekivanog pozitivnog, tj. konstruktivnog delovanja, mogu da deluju i destruktivno po nacionalnu bezbednost. Na drugoj strani, on tvrdi da strane obaveštajne službe, pored pretežno destruktivnog delovanja na nacionalnu bezbednost drugih država, mogu da deluju i pozitivno na njih. Ponudivši brojne dokaze za obe ove tvrdnje, autor zaključuje da je odnos obaveštajnih službi i nacionalne bezbednosti mnogo složeniji nego što se mnogima čini i da ne trpi nikakva pojednostavljivanja i olako lansirane šeme.
|