2014, vol. 5, br. 2, str. 231-239
|
U kojoj meri DNK može pružiti čvrst dokaz?
To what extent can DNA provide robust evidence?
University College London, Department of Security and Crime Science, London, United Kingdom
e-adresa: jovana.sretenov@gmail.com
Sažetak
U radu ćemo najpre opisati koncept analize DNK u svrhe rešavanja krivičnih slučajeva, i prve slučajeve u kojima je DNK korišćena kao forenzički dokaz. Potom ćemo ispitati savremena naučna i pravna pitanja koja se tiču upotrebe DNK u krivičnim postupcima, pri čemu ćemo pred- ložiti načine koji mogu učiniti forenzičku analizu DNK još čvršćim dokazom na sudu. Takođe ćemo se ukratko osvrnuti na etička pitanja koja se tiču DNK dokaza i DNK baza podataka.
Abstract
The author introduces the concept of DNA analysis for criminal casework starting with the definition of Forensic Science as an applied science which collects and analyses material traces found on crime scenes with the aim to determine the relationship between the trace and the crime incident, as well as to interpret and present the evidence in court. The paper explains how the field of science merges with the fields of law, policing and the wider political, social and economic context in which they all operate. Forensic DNA analysis and its roots in classical genetics, biochemistry and molecular biology are addressed, including key current challenges concerning forensic DNA analysis for crime purposes, which aim to explain laboratory results in court to people who have very limited knowledge of forensics and its methods and techniques. The use of DNA analysis for criminal casework after its introduction in the late 1980s is explained, including analyses of the history and current scientific and legal issues concerning DNA analyses. The difficulties that expert witnesses encounter in courts due to different principles that exists in law and science in general are also highlighted. The paper also addresses ethical issues regarding DNA evidence and DNA databases and finishes with a couple of recommendations that could facilitate more robust application of DNA analyses. The author advocates for the introduction of clear procedural and technical standards regarding admissibility of DNA evidence that must be legally set in order to produce robust court evidence, including efforts at the international level aimed at regulating the use of DNA analysis for forensic purposes among different countries.
|