Metrics

  • citations in SCIndeks: [2]
  • citations in CrossRef:[1]
  • citations in Google Scholar:[]
  • visits in previous 30 days:37
  • full-text downloads in 30 days:29

Contents

article: 10 from 22  
Back back to result list
The legal understanding of intentional medical error
International University of Novi Pazar

emailmirzatotic@yahoo.com
Abstract
The paper is devoted to doctor, a professional and humanist who dedicated himself to medicine and is committed to lifelong learning, ethics and assistance to victims, even against their express consent. The theme is focused on the problem of intentional medical error in order to negate it in the context that the conscientious doctors should be protected from tort and free of moral burden. This paper seeks to answer the question, if the error represents a doctor's failure to the detriment of the user (patient), how should we treat his attempt, made professionally and with the best intentions, regardless of the fatal outcome? In addition, medical-legal theory and practice beside intentional medical mistake mention also the unintentional, whose formation does not require any kind of responsibility because the doctor's behavior in that case was not inconsistent with medical ethics, standards and rules. In this regard, the author's research was based on the following questions: is there a deliberate medical error, who is ready to knowingly endanger the patient by doing medical procedures contrary to the rules (neglect, avoidance of assistance, misdiagnosis, improper treatment, indifference, discrimination), who is competent to qualify the taken action as an error (intentional, unintentional) and what evidences are required for the brutal attack on the integrity of top experts, that will be charged and prosecuted? Literature abounds with assertions that medical errors are as old as medicine, which is not true. Also, it is incorrect to say that it had appeared for the first time in the middle of the nineteenth century. That would be a roughly canceling of ancient medical marking, bearing in mind that even before the mentioned period, there had been a very successful medicine with high quality doctors and their brilliant achievements, but also with illnesses and dead persons. As far the data on the exact occurrence of medical errors are considered, the numerous authors claim that it does not have to be communicated, since it is placed in the field of history, that unlike many science is not exact, and should not always be considered as reliable. Any medical error makes a multiple interests, firstly of the researchers in the true sense of the word, and secondly, of the sensationalist columnists. The latter see the culprit only in the doctor, because many of them never presented the scene when defeated doctor leaves the Service ambulance, clinic, emergency room or any other health care area, because the most terrible thing in the profession has happened -the lost of a patient. Sensationalists are rarely present when despair and tears are being replaced by joy, smile and exaltation. They do not understand that it is impossible to meet the doctor who will be prepared to deliberately violate the profession, ethical values, Hippocratic oath, to directly endanger the health or life of the patient, or make a deliberate mistake and commit an offense.
References
Alldred, D.P., Standage, C., Zermansky, A.G., Jesson, B., Savage, I., Franklin, B.D., Barber, N., Raynor, D.K. (2008) Development and validation of criteria to identify medication-monitoring errors in care home residents. International Journal of Pharmacy Practice, 16(5): 317-323
Cha, A.E. (2016) Researchers: Medical errors now third leading cause of death in United States: To your health. Washington Post, Todays World View Newsletter, May 3
Deutsch, E. (1997) Medizinrecht Arztrecht, Arzneimittelrecht und Medizinprodukterecht. Berlin: Springer
Katzenmeier, C. (2002) Ist ein deutscher... Arzthaftung. Tübingen: J.C.B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck), S. 636
Laufs, A. (2003) Der mündige, aber leichtsinnige Patient. NJW, H. 32
Mchale, J., Fox, M., Gunn, M., Wilkinson, S. (2007) Health care law: Text and materials. London, pp. 151-154
McKee, M., Baeten, R., ur. (2008) Patient mobility in the European Union: Learning from experience. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe
McKee, M., Mossialos, E., Belcher, P. (1996) The Influence of European Law On National Health Policy. Journal of European Social Policy, 6(4): 263-286
Mićović, P. (2008) Zdravstveni menadžment - menadžment zdravstvenog sistema i zdravstvenih ustanova. Beograd: IP Obeležja, str. 342
Mićović, P.M. (2000) Menadžment zdravstvenog sistema. Beograd: Evropski centar za mir i razvoj (ECPD) Univerziteta za mir Ujedinjenih nacija
Mujović-Zornić, H. (2004) Lekarska greška - medicinski ili pravni pojam?. Svet rada, Vol. 1, 6, str. 821
Mujović-Zornić, H. (2015) Sudsko veštačenje u medicini rada. in: Udruženje sudskih veštaka u medicini rada (petnaesti simpozijum), Zbornik radova, Beograd, str. 8-19
Mujović-Zornić, H. (2010) Odnos građanske i krivične odgovornosti za slučaj medicinskih šteta. in: Aktualnosti građanskog i trgovačkog zakonodavstva i pravne prakse, Mostar, str. 394-395
Mujović-Zornić, H. (2011) Medicinske greške u okvirima građanskopravne odgovornosti. Strani pravni život, br. 3, str. 98-112
N.N. (2014) Na smrt osuđena lekarka koja je trgovala bebama. Večernje novosti, str. 9, 15. januar
Nenadović, M. (2007) Medicinska etika - pismo Paula Mantegaca sinu. Beograd: Univerzitet u Prištini - Medicinski fakultet, (pismo u celini preuzeto iz Medicinska etika, 1992. godine, autora prof. dr Dimitrija P. Milovanovića); str. 224-226
Nenadović, M. (2007) Medicinska etika - kineska medicina. Beograd: Univerzitet u Prištini - Medicinski fakultet, str. 121-123
Radišić, J. (2007) Odgovornost zbog štete izazvane lekarskom greškom u lečenju i u obaveštavanju pacijenta. Beograd: Nomos
Radišić, J. (2008) Medicinsko pravo. Beograd: IP Nomos, str. 58
Schreiber, H.L. (1995) Der Standard der erforderlichen Sorgfalt als Haftungsinstrument. Versicherungsmedizin, 1, str. 3
Sieiglitz, S. (1989) Die Wrongful birth und Wrongful life Problematik im deutschen Deliktsrecht. München, S. 196
Stauch, M., Wheat, K., Tingle, J. (1999) Sourcebook on medical law. London - Sydney, pp. 275-307
Škorić, M. (2007) Pravna regulacija reproduktivnog i terapeutskog kloniranja na međunarodnoj i nacionalnoj razini. Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilište, Rijeka, br. 2, str. 1244
Templton, Dž.M. (2012) Knjiga životnih zakona - 200 večnih duhovnih načela iz celog sveta. Beograd: Mladinska knjiga, str. 520
Totić, I. (2016) Ekonomika zdravstva Državni univerzitet u Novom Pazaru. Novi Pazar, str. 343
Vukmanović, Č.L. (1994) Menadžment u zdravstvu politika i strategija zdravstvenog razvoja. Beograd: Savremena administracija
Vuori, H. (1981) Primary health care in industrialized countries. Zurich: Die Allegemeinpraxis, pp. 83-111
Wren, D.A., Voich, D.V. (1994) Menadžment (proces, struktura i ponašanje). Beograd: Grmeč, str. 449
Zimmerman, A. (1999) Anti-Semitism as Skill: Rudolf Virchow's Schulstatistik and the Racial Composition of Germany. Central European History, 32(04): 409
 

About

article language: Serbian, English
document type: unclassified
DOI: 10.5937/medgla1764033T
published in SCIndeks: 21/05/2017
Creative Commons License 4.0

Related records