- citati u SCIndeksu: [2]
- citati u CrossRef-u:0
- citati u Google Scholaru:[
]
- posete u poslednjih 30 dana:3
- preuzimanja u poslednjih 30 dana:0
|
|
2007, vol. 24, br. 7-8, str. 10-21
|
Krivično-pravna zaštita životne sredine prema novom Krivičnom zakoniku Srbije
Criminal and legal protection of health environment according to the new Criminal code of the Republic of Serbia
Univerzitet Privredna akademija u Novom Sadu
Sažetak
Činjenica je da je novi Krivični zakonik Srbije po prvi put sistematizovao brojna krivična dela kojima se primarno štiti životna sredina u jednu glavu (XXIV) koja i nosi naslov "Krivična dela protiv životne sredine". Ovakvo postupanje zakonodavca predstavlja veliki napredak, kako u Krivičnom zakonodavstvu Srbije, tako i u Krivičnom pravu, teoriji i u nauci s obzirom da je na postupljeni način razrešena već odavno postavljena dilema u teoriji i nauci krivičnog prava da li životna sredina treba da predstavlja samostalni i primarni zaštitni objekat krivičnih dela protiv životne sredine ili se istima štite neka klasična pravna dobra - život i zdravlje ljudi, na koje pitanje je takođe već davno dat pravilan odgovor koji se ogleda u konstataciji da je s obzirom na značaj životne sredine i njenu zaštitu opravdano je postaviti kao samostalan i primarni zaštitni objekt bar kod nekih inkriminacija. U Krivičnom zakoniku je upravo tako i postupljeno sa konstatacijom u krivično-pravnoj teoriji da u vezi sa određivanjem zaštitnog objekta krivičnih dela protiv životne sredine više nije sporno da se njima više ne štite klasična pravna dobra - život i zdravlje ljudi (od novih oblika napada na njih kroz ugrožavanje životne sredine), već samostalno dobro a to je životna sredina, tačnije rečeno pravo čoveka na očuvanu životnu sredinu. S obzirom na značaj životne sredine i njenu zaštitu, opravdano je postaviti je kao samostalan i primarni grupni zaštitni objekt.
Abstract
A conclusion drawn from the presented ideas in this article, is that the protected object in this type of crime, in the national and international criminal legislation, lies in the fundamental human right to healthy and relatively protected environment, and in health environment itself as specific right that serves to the protection of elementary human rights accepted as universal values. Only by having criminal protection of health environment, as being specific entity, it is possible to have criminal protection of fundamental human rights, i.e. right to life, right to health right to privacy and family life, right to property and information on the risks. The new Criminal Code is based on these values and is merging ecocentric and anthropocentric views. All crimes that primarily have to protect environment as specific universal value, are systematized in part XXIV of the Criminal Code, and the heading of that part is: Crimes against health environment. The third reason in favor of such conclusion is formulated in a way that by determining the protected object of crimes against health environment, it is not protected life and health of people but health environment as a specific value, that is, right to health environment. Having in mind the importance of health environment and its protection, it is justifiable to have it as specific and primary grouped protected object. Long time ago, it has been the topic of discussion how important is to deal with the criminal liability of legal entities in relation to protection of health environment. It is very rarely that a need to prescribe criminal sanctions for delicate behavior of legal entities is underlined like in this area. Ecological crime problematic is requiring review of criminal liability of legal entities. Without over exaggerating, we can say that it is a trend towards introducing criminal liability of legal entities. Ecological catastrophes caused by legal entities with very hard consequences, environment pollution…. have put the question before us whether we can still ignore the criminal behavior of legal entities. Many crimes like environment pollution… are not only crimes of an individual, but more and more of a legal entity. All the above questions are forcing our system to introduce criminal liability of legal entities into our criminal legislation and liability of legal entities with the noted tendency of introducing this liability into the area of ecological crime. Criminal and ecological liability (including legal entities liability) should be only subjective. The main obstacle in reaching the purpose of imposing sanctions against legal entities was until to date that there has been only objective liability of legal entities for commercial crime. Due to that fact, the minimal subjectivisation has been proposed, that is limited objective liability of legal entities for this kind of crime. In present time, it seems acceptable to continue with the subjectivisation of liability of legal entities, since it is possible, if we have in mind the culpability of liable person as the key precondition for the existence of liability of legal entity, and constituting the culpability of legal entity in the normative sense. It is of most importance to pass the Law on Liability of Legal Entities for Crimes, as it has been done in many European countries and in the region.
|
|
|
Reference
|
|
*** (2005) Krivični zakonik Srbije. Službeni glasnik RS, br. 85 od 06. 10
|
|
*** (1992) Nouveau code pénal. Paris: Mode d'emploi
|
|
*** (1994) Krivični zakonik. Uredni list Republike Slovenije, br. 63, od 13. 10
|
|
*** (1999) Zakon o odgovornosti pravnih lica za krivična dela. Uredni list Republike Slovenije, br. 59, od 23. 07
|
|
*** (2002) Zakon o potvrđivanju krivičnopravne konvencije o korupciji. Službeni list SRJ, Međunarodni ugovori, br. 2, od 01. 03
|
1
|
Cetinić, M.M. (2005) Kaznena odgovornost pravnih lica - kakva rešenja su moguća i očekivana. u: Kazneno zakonodavstvo - progresivna ili regresivna rešenja, Beograd, str. 239
|
2
|
Čejović, B.M. (1982) Krivična dela protiv čovekove sredine. Pravni život, br. 2, str. 187
|
6
|
Đorđević, M.Đ. (1969) Sistem privrednih delikata. Jugoslovenska revija za kriminologiju i krivično pravo, vol. 7, br. 4, str. 536
|
2
|
Krstić, I. (2005) Pravo na zdravu životnu sredinu u korpusu ljudskih prava. Pravni život, vol. 54, br. 9, str. 609-622
|
39
|
Lazarević, L.V. (2006) Komentar Krivičnog zakonika Republike Srbije. Beograd: Savremena administracija
|
6
|
Lazarević, L.V. (1969) Krivična odgovornost u javnim službama i preduzećima. u: Francusko-jugoslovenski pravnički dani (10), Niš, referat
|
|
Panović-Đurić, S.V. (1995) Osvrt na krivično-pravnu zaštitu čovekove sredine: Uporedni pregled. Pravni život, vol. 44, br. 9, str. 303-316
|
|
Paunović, M. Međunarodno-pravna zaštita životinja sa osvrtom na zaštitu životinja u Srbiji i Crnoj Gori. Prava čoveka, br. 1-2, str. 9, 24-25
|
2
|
Perović, S.K. (2002) Prirodno pravo kao mera svetskog poretka. u: XV susreti pravnika Kopaoničke škole prirodnog prava održanom na Kopaoniku od 13-17. decembra godine, 2002 - uvodna reč, str. 25
|
8
|
Rakić-Vodinelić, V.R. (1995) Ekološko pravo kao pravo čoveka. Pravni život, vol. 44, br. 9, str. 245-266
|
5
|
Salma, J. (1995) Načela i sistem ekološkog prava. Pravni život, vol. 44, br. 9, str. 267-280
|
8
|
Simović-Hiber, I. (1995) Krivična odgovornost pravnih lica i privredni prestupi - da li je razlikovanje samo terminološke prirode?. Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu, vol. 43, br. 3, str. 210-224
|
3
|
Stojanović, Z. (1990) Odgovornost pravnog lica za privredne prestupe. Pravna misao, br. 3-4, str. 90
|
30
|
Stojanović, Z.P., Perić, O.M. (2006) Krivično pravo - posebni deo. Beograd: Pravna knjiga
|
95
|
Stojanović, Z.P. (2005) Krivično pravo - opšti deo. Beograd: Službeni glasnik
|
4
|
Stojanović, Z.P. (1995) Krivično-pravna zaštita životne sredine: Neki aspekti zakonodavnog regulisanja. Pravni život, vol. 44, br. 9, str. 291-301
|
2
|
Škulić, M.Z. (2001) Krivičnopravna zaštita životne sredine. Pravni život, vol. 50, br. 9, str. 257-280
|
|
Todić, D. (2005) Novi zakoni Republike Srbije u oblasti životne sredine i univerzalne vrednosti. Pravni život, vol. 54, br. 9, str. 573-586
|
|
Vrhovšek, M. (2002) Zakon o potvrđivanju konvencija donetih na međunarodnom planu u oblasti krivičnog prava. Human Rights, br. 7-8, str. 9-10
|
4
|
Vrhovšek, M. (2002) Nešto više o ratifikovanim međunarodnim konvencijama iz oblasti krivičnog prava. Pravo - teorija i praksa, vol. 19, br. 11, str. 3-10
|
|
|
|